Uh, so I know I've been gone, for like, EVER, but I've been busy at Tell-Thai Heart. (Quit with the excuses woman!) But that doesn't stop people from sharing their Waldorf experiences or regarding questions.
And it's unbelievably nourishing and helpful. Thank you.
Okay, so why am I writing? Well, my latest email told me she heard about me through WaldorfWatch.com, so I FINALLY went looking for the exact entry and this is what I found:
Yeah! I know. I'm amazing. And the quote! *blush, blush* Thank you Waldorf Watch.
I try to be objective and not anti-Waldorf but shucks, if you keep saying things like this about me - well - I just might have to change my mind ;)
16 May 2013
06 January 2013
Where I'm at
I’m in a
writers group. And I’ve been reading this blog book to them. As a result, this
book has become a joy again and not something I’m just trying to finish and
trudge through.
Prior to
that, when I thought I was finished, I had 3 dear friends read everything cover
to cover and give me valuable advice, opinions and grammar pointers! So I have
been re-reading it, editing it and posting the updated version, which you can
see under ‘chapters’ on the right side.
My goal was
to have this finally put to rest by the end of 2012 but the writers group has
encouraged me to take my time. And I must say I feel extremely blessed to have readers
and listeners from different English speaking countries and women from their
20s to their 80s give me their feedback and thoughts.
We honestly
have each decade represented in our all-women’s writers group (well, from me up)! I remember I put
the advertisement out there and forgot about it when no was interested. Then
Catherine contacted me, we met, then she introduced me to other fine ladies.
Folks came and went as the expat community goes. The group died and then it was
picked up again and now it is flourishing.
Also.
It’s
interesting. This blog book is no longer the catharsis or burden it once was, instead
it’s become a way to connect with people. I had a nice young man email me
towards the end of last year, and we met because he also lives in Chiang Mai
and wanted to ask about being a Waldorf teacher!
I hear there
is a eurthymy teacher living on my street somewhere!? I have yet to meet him
but my friend Ingrid knows him. And one of the dear ladies from the writers
group just told me her friend in Lampang was a Waldorf teacher. She wants to
meet me and I can’t wait to dish!
All this to
say, I’m not sure what will happen when I am finished finished with this
blog book, so in the meantime I will enjoy the walk down the road this Waldorf experience
is taking me.
12 December 2012
Touchy Parents
Parents act REALLY touchy and touché when you bring up any
thoughts, suggestions or advice regarding their parenting. I understand. I used
to feel that way about my teaching. But the difference with teaching is usually
you are having a planned discussion about your teaching style. And as I have
gained more experience, I know how to separate the chaff from the rice.
My friend Jen posted on Facebook about a couple of women
watching and commenting on her husband’s “rough” handling of their child. She
was pissed because she knows her husband is a good father and wouldn’t do
anything to jeopardize their son’s health and safety. Gender stereotyping Nevertheless, I thought Jen’s angry
reaction was interesting considering her easygoing personality.
During an all-women’s writers group, I mentioned this
incident. And one of the women mentioned how she would always get nervous when
her husband threw or tossed their child in the air and how a cartoon made her
laugh about it. The cartoon showed the child’s perception of the distance
between father and him – too close to daddy, and the mother’s perception which
was the baby being tossed up to the ceiling.
Then the women started talking about how those women were
just being “over protective” as is in their nature, and how they would understand
Jen getting upset because the father’s behavior shows a reflection of her
mothering. And when I mentioned Jen is a doula, they were like, Okay! It all
makes sense now!!!!
I recently posted this article on FB from Details magazine
called, Are
you raising a douche bag? And surprisingly, my brother got really agitated
by it. In fact, as I type, I can see he is responding to our discussion because
I thought the article was good and he did not.
One of the things that bothered me about Waldorf was I knew
I was working with entitled or rich kids. Waldorf education is an expensive
one. Now let me be clear, I know we want to give our children the best but I
come from a different background. I’d put my family on the low-middle class
scale, blue collar, and spare the rod spoil the child kind of thing.
I also come from an ethnically diverse State, Hawaii, so I
was also very aware of the lack of “color” or diversity in my classroom and the
school. Heck, Portland is pretty monochromatic. I felt the class or economic differences created a lot of misunderstandings between me and the parents, and maybe even some of the faculty too.
I used to get incensed over politics, I still get stupid
angry over drivers, and like any asshole without kids, I certainly have options
about childrearing. I guess because I’ve been reared before.
One of the biggest criticisms I received as a young Waldorf
teacher was I didn’t have any children, so what could I possibly know about
them. This deeply hurt because I loved
my students as if they were my own and had dedicated myself to teaching. Enter
sob story here.
Now I just think, “You are absolutely right.” All I know is from what I see and observe
when I’m in the classroom or when I’m interacting with your child. I realize
parents want to be held accountable for the brilliant and great things their
child does and congress a “hands off policy” when their child behaves badly.
I’d be the same way I’m sure.
But if there is one thing I’ve learned from my failed
Waldorf experience, from watching my friends and family raise kids, from
teaching English in foreign countries, it’s this: R E L A X your balls.
Breathe. Don’t take everything so seriously.
Folks are going to have many opinions and thoughts about you
that you might feel are mostly false and downright wrong but there is nothing
you can do to change it. Trust me, I’ve tried.
I can only say this now because I wonder how my Waldorf
career would have turned out had I been more understanding, compassionate and less
touchy. This is not to validate or
justify what some of the faculty and parents did, but I don’t think wishing you
were more compassionate and understanding is a bad thing. Or is it?
Labels:
parents
10 November 2012
Is Waldorf a cult?
Okay. Those of you who know me and who know how long I've been working on this blog of a book, you know, you know how I struggle with "Should I let it rest? Let it go? or Just publish the damn thing already?!" But recent feedback has made me rethink the beginning and ending. So this is my new beginning or prologue. I mean, as much as I love my shitting in my pants story, I think it's time for a clearer direction. What do you think? Well, here it is:
“I feel like I've learned a lot about you today.”
“Why?”
“Well, I never really understood why getting fired from Waldorf was such a big deal for you. I only knew that you really liked that job. But now I get it, Waldorf is a cult. It messed with your head.”
I fought my reaction to say, “It’s not a cult.” Instead I replied, “Well, that is Waldorf’s biggest criticism. But I don’t know if it’s a cult…”
My friend stared at me, “You just told me you were criticized for being irreverent. You didn’t fit in to their dogma or beliefs. You didn't act the way they wanted you to. Somehow you must have slipped through the system, and when you didn't change, they fired you.”
That was succinct.
“I suppose...I just think people associate cults with weak minded people. And I'm not weak.”
“No you're not. And I don't think that at all. I think a lot of people who get into cults are looking for something, for answers, they're seekers.”
It’s been about 10 years since my Waldorf experience, so I understand a little better, how folks would think Waldorf education is a cult. But what isn't a cult these days? According to the Wiki, "The word cult in current popular usage usually refers to a new religious movement or other group whose beliefs or practices are considered abnormal or bizarre.The word originally denoted a system of ritual practices."
But when we look at these examples at Listverse, I want to laugh. I mean seriously. When I was immersed in the Waldorf world of fairy tales, watercolors and silk cloths, I’d say it was just magical. It was fun. It was as childhood should be. Gnomes arereal dolls, and dolls with no faces were fine by me. Better no eyes, nose and mouth than one that I wished looked different.
Yet there is no denying, Rudolf Steiner advocates, and Waldorf educators fight any dogmatic leashes that the critics saddle upon them. I see it as they believe they are normal and other people think they are not, hence the word "cult" gets tossed around like a hot potato or a bill in Congress. So is Waldorf a cult? Up to you.
What do I think? It’s almost like Christianity pretending not to be a religion. Would Waldorf folks feel more comfortable it they were labeled as a culture or way of life? Because Waldorf cannot deny there are rules and ideals, and a set of practices and beliefs. Waldorf is a way of life, it’s a culture. This can be good or bad or neither.
I currently live in Thailand as an American Asian expat and have been wrestling with this culture question. And I don't think it would serve anybody to get into it here. But I think it's another way to look at this Waldorf as a cult question. And yes, I realize the word "cult" is in culture…
“I feel like I've learned a lot about you today.”
“Why?”
“Well, I never really understood why getting fired from Waldorf was such a big deal for you. I only knew that you really liked that job. But now I get it, Waldorf is a cult. It messed with your head.”
I fought my reaction to say, “It’s not a cult.” Instead I replied, “Well, that is Waldorf’s biggest criticism. But I don’t know if it’s a cult…”
My friend stared at me, “You just told me you were criticized for being irreverent. You didn’t fit in to their dogma or beliefs. You didn't act the way they wanted you to. Somehow you must have slipped through the system, and when you didn't change, they fired you.”
That was succinct.
“I suppose...I just think people associate cults with weak minded people. And I'm not weak.”
“No you're not. And I don't think that at all. I think a lot of people who get into cults are looking for something, for answers, they're seekers.”
***
It’s been about 10 years since my Waldorf experience, so I understand a little better, how folks would think Waldorf education is a cult. But what isn't a cult these days? According to the Wiki, "The word cult in current popular usage usually refers to a new religious movement or other group whose beliefs or practices are considered abnormal or bizarre.The word originally denoted a system of ritual practices."
But when we look at these examples at Listverse, I want to laugh. I mean seriously. When I was immersed in the Waldorf world of fairy tales, watercolors and silk cloths, I’d say it was just magical. It was fun. It was as childhood should be. Gnomes are
Yet there is no denying, Rudolf Steiner advocates, and Waldorf educators fight any dogmatic leashes that the critics saddle upon them. I see it as they believe they are normal and other people think they are not, hence the word "cult" gets tossed around like a hot potato or a bill in Congress. So is Waldorf a cult? Up to you.
What do I think? It’s almost like Christianity pretending not to be a religion. Would Waldorf folks feel more comfortable it they were labeled as a culture or way of life? Because Waldorf cannot deny there are rules and ideals, and a set of practices and beliefs. Waldorf is a way of life, it’s a culture. This can be good or bad or neither.
I currently live in Thailand as an American Asian expat and have been wrestling with this culture question. And I don't think it would serve anybody to get into it here. But I think it's another way to look at this Waldorf as a cult question. And yes, I realize the word "cult" is in culture…
Labels:
waldorf education
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

